Scoville Units Unite

02 Apr

Dodger – Terry Pratchett


Dodger follows on from The Long Earth in being a non-Discworld book. I’m not sure whether this is an attempt to hide Pratchetts changing writers voice when working on Discworld novels or simply a way to leave a non-Discworld legacy with some ideas he has but it is a welcome change. I remember reading a story about an interview with a journalist who seemed incredulous that Pratchett was famous I’ve never heard of you was met with a response along the lines of well I’ve been in the bestsellers list with at least one book constantly for the last 20 years. Unfortunately writing fantasy which satires politics, religion and real people means you are somewhat overlooked. The Long Earth was a really good book which makes you think about limited resources and morality even though it focuses on one super being.

Dodger, unfortunately is not as good. A view of Victorian London from the gutter. The main character, Dodger, feels like he would fit in in the Shades. The constant references to people and Victorian London seem forced and unsubtle. Unlike Discworld where they are peppered throughout but only ever explained in footnotes if explained at all, here they are crow-barred in. One part is essentially, Oh you are telling me about the living conditions of the poor? My friend Charles who recently came here as a refugee is interested in that and is writing books on the subject, I’ll be sure to pass these comments on. The journalist Charles Dickens scribbling little phrases in his book and so on lampshade what would otherwise be passages to cause a smirk. These spoil what would otherwise be an enjoyable tale.

But, taking a break from Ankh-Morpork to write a less funny book set in a place which inspired huge chunks of Ankh-Morpork doesn’t really work. I’d only recommend to completists or those who have a love for pre-20th century literature and it’s parodies. e.g. You love Dickens or enjoy the Pride and Prejudice + Current Popular Meme Monster/Creature books.

2 Responses to “Dodger – Terry Pratchett”

  1. 1
    Melissa Scholefield Says:

    I have to say I’ve read ‘Nation’ which was a fairly recent TP book that was non-Discworld and I really couldn’t get into it. I read ‘Unseen Academicals’ which is also new and loved that so I don’t think it can just be his changing writing style – maybe the books just lose something without that huge world he’s taken so many years to create.

  2. 2
    Alan Graham Says:

    I think that’s part of it too, but maybe the world has become bugger than his writing and he wants to show he’s an author ‘proper’ before his imminent demise. I enjoyed Nation, but Red Strangers is one of my favourite novels so I enjoy the books about colonialism which view the colonialists a the weirdos

Leave a Reply

© 2024 Scoville Units Unite | Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS)

Powered by Wordpress, design by Web4 Sudoku, based on Pinkline by GPS Gazette